Educomp Files Complaint Against ‘malicious s’
{image}
Educomp Files Complaint Against ‘malicious s’
Free Online Articles Directory
ABAnswers
0 && $ .browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($ .browser.version);
if(ie_version
via
Hello
Password
Lost ?
Home Page > Finance > Investing > Educomp Files Complaint Against ‘malicious s’
Educomp Files Complaint Against ‘malicious s’
Edit Article |
Posted: Jan 22, 2009 |Comments: 1
|
With a heightened sense of alertness among investors and brokerages after the Satyam fiasco, rumours have been flying thick about various companies, the actions of their promoters, and the scale of their businesses. Educomp Solutions, a leading provider of education services has been the target of various such rumours about the company’s wage bill, debtor days, promoters selling stake and pledging shares, its auditors and debt position.
Reacting to the allegations, Shantanu Prakash, Managing Director of Educomp Solutions, said many of the rumours have been floated by people, “who do not understand our business model.” Rumours about directors quitting the company and promoters pledging stake, he said, were baseless.
Prakash said the promoters of the company have not pledged any share and that just 5% of their stake has been sold over three years for personal needs. “The total number of shares sold is 8.76 lakh and it’s only 5.07% of the fully-diluted share capital company in three years.”
“On January 27, when we disclose our Q3 earnings, we are going to unveil a corporate governance roadmap and that is going to address some of the corporate governance issues very comprehensively,” Prakash said.
Here is a verbatim transcript of Shantanu Prakash’s exclusive interview on CNBC-TV18.
Q: There have been allegations — and Educomp has issued clarifications — but we want you to talk on this issue: the salary bill of 3,955 employees is below Rs 34 crore. That doesn’t sound realistic.
A: Whoever has spread this news has totally not understood the business model of the company.
As you might be aware, we work very extensively with government and private schools as well as with private schools. Whenever we work with a government school, we post one lab assistant in each school. These employees — who are typically entry-level, just-graduated people, mostly into their first jobs — form the bulk of our workforce. We have about 3,500 employees that are deployed in various government and private schools across the country.
The typical salary of a person who is deployed in a rural government school is between Rs 3,500 to Rs 4,000 a month and a person who is deployed in a private school is Rs 7,000 to Rs 8,000 a month. To look at this and compare it to the salary of a programmer in an IT company, that’s a completely baseless comparison.
We are not an IT company but an education company. You can’t compare apples and oranges and draw a completely misleading conclusion.
Q: What is the percentage of employees who, earn under Rs 4,000 per month?
A: Over 70% of our employees and that’s the bulk of our workforce.
Q: The debtor days is an important issue that has been raised by some of the analysts earlier too. It has come down from 176 in FY06 to around 145. Could you clarify that because in the delegations report, they mentioned that it is around eight months?
A: That’s another example of how the numbers have been twisted around. It’s a well-known fact that Educomp’s business model is a build-own-operate-and-transfer model in which we charge the institution on a quarterly basis post the quarter — so that’s about 90 days. In addition, it takes about 30 days to collect [the payment], so that’s about 120 days and when we are working with government we take anywhere from 45 to 60 days to collect the payment, so the working capital cycle in that case can be as much as 150-160 days.
It’s a well-known fact about Educomp’s business model. Due to efficient collection and other lines of businesses, our debtor days have been consistently declining quarter-on-quarter since the company went public. It has come down from 179 days to 145 days now.
Q: So you are saying eight months is not right?
A: Anyone who can read our annual report and do basic arithmetic can know that this statement is false.
Q: There is one allegation that about 14 lakh shares have been sold by promoters to the extent of about Rs 250 crore since the IPO came out. Why are the promoters on a selling spree if you have so much confidence in your business?
A: The founders and promoters of the company have not sold a single share in the past approximately six months. Whenever you do, by law, you have to make a disclosure to the stock exchanges.
The disclosure [for whatever shares sold in the past] has been duly made. We have submitted a detailed date-by-date account of the shares sold and the total number is 8.76 lakh and that is only 5.07% of the fully-diluted share capital company in three years.
Q: Why do you need to reduce your holding from 60% to 55% within two years of coming out with an IPO. Why did you reduce your holding by 5%?
A: The promoters still own over 55% of the stock in the company.
Q: Yes but 60% in itself is not an unusually high number. There was no requirement for you per se to sell this 5% stake. So was there any specific reason to do so?
A: [The stake sale was] for personal needs and to create liquidity for the promoters. I would also like to clarify here that there have also been some other rumours about promoters having pledged their shares. We have repeatedly clarified that there is not a single share of the promoter that is pledged in any form with any financial or non-financial [institution].
Q: Have you sold any share after the price came down from Rs 5,500 to Rs 2,000 odd?
A: No. In fact, the average selling price, and it’s instructional to know, is approximately Rs 2,000 a share. So we never took advantage of the high prices. The bulk of the shares were sold at less than Rs 1,200/share.
Q: We know that the auditors of the company are Anupum Bansal & Co. There remains a question mark, but given the huge size of your company, could you shed more light on Anupam Bansal & Co — the auditors of the firm?
A: It has been our auditor for the past few years and we are quite satisfied with its service. It is a reputed local Indian firm but apart from that, we are one of the few companies that have got two sets of internal auditors to grill our financials.
On January 27, in fact, when we disclose our Q3 earnings, we are going to unveil a corporate governance roadmap and that is going to address some of the corporate governance issues very comprehensively.
It is our aspiration that Educomp should be one of the top 10 companies in India as far as corporate governance is concerned. We have always set a standard for disclosures in the education industry. If you compare Educomp’s disclosure with any of our peer company, you will see our disclosures are the most detailed ones.
Q: Coming back to the 5% share sale, was this in an open market. If that was the case, could you not have come out with a private placement offer?
A: They have been sold in very small lots. They have been sold in the open market — 20,000, 30,000, 40,000 shares at a time.
Q: That is exactly my point because in that case why couldn’t you have not come out with a private placement because I am assuming with this 5% stake sale, with the market price of Rs 2,000 you would have made more money by divesting the money in IPO in the first place, so the only question is: could there have been a private placement in place of selling 5% stake in open market?
A: You also have to note that it’s over a period of three years and there is no consistent pattern for that at all. There is not a premeditated plan to diversify because it’s been coming down over a period of time in very small increments and we still own 55% of the stock of the company.
So looking at it from an overall perspective, a 5% dilution is not a substantial dilution.
Q: Have any of your independent directors resigned in the past several weeks?
A: None in the past several weeks.
Q: Have any resigned in the past six months?
A: Not even in the past six months.
Q: One of the charges made by one of the brokerages is that you simply bought too many goods, too many computers in the ratio of 1:1?
A: It again shows that the person does not understand what the fundamental business of the company is.
The company is in the business of entering into a contract with schools, where we install computer equipment, so obviously we will buy computers. In each classroom — and it’s a five-year contract — the school pays us for five years and it’s a highly profitable business. So if we install computers worth Rs 1,00,000 in year one, we get back Rs 1,00,000 almost in the same year but we continue to earn for five years.
So if you don’t understand the business model you will come up with queries like these or it might be deliberately given information.
Q: Has the company taken loan from some of the banks, the market was talking about somewhere between Rs 800-900 crore?
A: No. That is completely wrong. All the company debts are regularly disclosed in each of our earnings calls.
The consolidated debt on the company — not including the FCCB — is approximately Rs 275 crore on a consolidated basis. For Educomp on a standalone basis, the debt is approximately Rs 40 crore and the FCCB outstanding amount is approximately about Rs 316 crore, which is due in June 2012.
Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/investing-articles/educomp-files-complaint-against-malicious-emails-733908.html”
(ArticlesBase SC #733908)
articles to Articlesbase.com, and watch your traffic increase. Click here to make it happen.
Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!
Sumita Kaul -
About the Author:
Questions and Answers
Ask our experts your Investing related questions here…
Ask
200 Characters left
Where do I find information and sample how to fill in complaint tort for wrongful death in a nursing home. Must file immediately or lose right. Too late for atty to review and file. Atty later. Thanks
Rate this Article
1
2
3
4
5
1
Feedback
Print
Re-Publish
Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/investing-articles/educomp-files-complaint-against-malicious-emails-733908.html
Article Tags:
educomp, educomp solutions, edu comp, satyam, maytas
Latest Investing Articles
More from Sumita Kaul
Top Tips to Learn from a Money Saving Expert
Staying along with your income and raising your monthly savings is the difficult of all tasks these days. The major reason behind this is the increasing expenses apart from inflation. The expense turns out to be much more than the monthly income hooking up your credit card bills landing up in big trouble with lot of debts and other loans
By:
Gianfranco Fracassil
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 13, 2011
Your Insurance Management Strategy For Low Cost Life Insurance Plans
Managing your insurance resources properly is important for you to understand which will help you in reaping better results. New ways have to be developed to manage your policy.
By:
David Livingstonl
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 13, 2011
Tsunami rocks Asia. Will the stock market plunge?
Several Japanese cities have been devastated by a massive tsunami. Buildings have been ripped apart, cars have been swept away. What will the impact be on the markets? Should you convert holdings to cash?
By:
Jeffrey Websterl
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 12, 2011
Portfolio Prophet ETF Trading Home Study Course AND Trade Alert Software By Bill Poulos
Bill’s finally going to be releasing his brand new, step-by-step trading program – the Portfolio Prophet – which includes his custom, intelligent Trade Alert Software
By:
Ahmad Hassaml
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 12, 2011
The Portfolio Prophet ,000 ETF Secret Weapon By Bill Poulos!
The ,000 ETF “secret weapon”? This “Portfolio Prophet” discovery 60-second ETF trading?! Your private financial “advisor”? If you’re like most forward-thinking, smart people, then you’ve probably been struggling with this question, especially with all the recent economic turmoil we’ve been experiencing…
By:
Ahmad Hassaml
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 12, 2011
The Need to keep track of the Gold Price
Check out www.indiangoldrates.com for today india gold price. You can even make the information reach you by sms or emails.
By:
indiangoldratel
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 12, 2011
Commodity Market – Bullions, Metals, Energy & Agri Products
Commodity markets are markets where raw or primary products are exchanged. These raw commodities are traded on regulated commodities exchanges, in which they are bought and sold in standardized contracts. Worldwide, there are 48 major commodity exchanges that trade over 96 commodities. The trading of commodities consists of direct physical trading and derivatives trading.
By:
Haril
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 12, 2011
Some Easy Steps to Save Money on Your Grocery Bill
If you will learn some important things about shopping then you may save your money to some extent and here is one of the best options for you to shop your groceries from peapod online store on discounted rates.
By:
Israel Kennedyl
Finance>
Investingl
Mar 12, 2011
Educomp Solutions- Educomp Denies Fraud Like Satyam Rumours, Accounts Fudging – Educomp Meets Sebi
Educomp denies accounts fudging & fraud like satyam rumours, Educomp meets SEBI Senior officials of Educomp Solutions Limited met SEBI in Mumbai and sought a probe by them into an alleged nexus between the recent slander campaign against the company and the unusual activity in the company’s stock.
By:
Sumita Kaull
Business>
Ethicsl
Jan 27, 2009
lViews: 1,081
Educomp Solutions – Educomp Signs an Agreement With Michael & Susan Dell Foundation
Educomp Solutions – Educomp Signs an Agreement with Michael & Susan Dell Foundation, Educomp Solutions, India’s largest education company has signed a services agreement with Michael & Susan Dell Foundation, a United States based private Charitable Foundation, for Rs 4.78 crores.
By:
Sumita Kaull
Business>
Online Businessl
Jan 24, 2009
lViews: 138
Add new Comment
Your :
Comments on this article
0
1. Ram 24/01/2009
Pretty much satisfied by the Replies given by the company. I have got full faith in the company.
Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy
Sign Up Today
My Home
View/Edit Q&A
Personal
My Home
View/Edit Q&A
Author Box
Sumita Kaul has 3 articles online
Contact Author
Subscribe to
Print article
Send to friend
Re-Publish article
Articles Categories
All Categories
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing
Finance
Accounting
Banking
Credit
Currency Trading
Day Trading
Debt Consolidation
Insurance
Investing
Loans
Mortgage
Personal Finance
Real Estate
Taxes
Wealth Building
Need Help?
Site Links
Mobile Version
Webmasters
Business Info
Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.